Here we go again…
As reliably as children are fooled by Santa Claus, the news media have once again been duped by an obviously false story that fits their favorite narrative about race. Last year, it was the Jussie Smollett fiasco, on which I was one of the first media commentators to call out as lacking credibility, today, in a very different but similar story, we have learned that, contrary to the enormous amount of media outrage. and moralizing, black NASCAR driver Bubba Wallace was not the victim of a noose-related hate crime.
For those who have somehow missed it, over the weekend NASCAR dramatically and declaratively announced that Wallace had been the target of a “noose” found in his garage at the Talladega speedway in Alabama. This was just before a high-profile race on that track that took place on Monday.
When I first heard the story, I assumed there had to be a photo of the noose in question, and was very curious to see how someone could be both so incredibly awful, as well as insanely stupid, as to do something so horrifically racist to. a black driver. It quickly became obvious, however, that there was no public photo, and my spidey senses began to tell me that something about this story was just not right.
This is my first of many tweets asking for people, and especially the media, to please not rush to judgment on a story where there could be many other scenarios that make far more sense than the narrative which has been very widely reported, as if it. was a certifiable fact: “Since many noose-related stories turn out to be frauds / misunderstandings, there should be skepticism here. It is a garage. A rope tied like that has even been noticed in someone else’s stall or at another time. Of course responds this time to wait for facts before assuming racism! ” Not surprisingly, I was attacked on Twitter for the next two days for being, at best, stupid, and, at worst, racist.
However, the lack of a photo was so inexplicable that it appeared obvious to me that this could have been a misunderstanding (under the presumption that if the noose / scene was really unambiguous, we would absolutely have seen a photo right away). At these times of extreme racial tension, and after NASCAR had just announced it was completely banning the Confederate flag from its events, it seemed to me that someone might have seen a simple rope with an open knot at the end of it, panicked, and. Then once the “noose” narrative got started, there was no way to contain it, especially in this current media atmosphere (for context, there have been two noose stories here in California over just the past week that have turned out not to be hateful). crimes).
Unfortunately, the modern news media, especially the sports media, does not pause for even a moment to consider other possible explanations, especially on stories that fit their agenda. ESPN in particular now appears to have only one gear, and no brakes, when it comes to reacting to stories that have either a racism or sexual abuse element to them.
So, led by ESPN, instead of doing basic journalism and waiting for at least some actual facts to come in, the entire industrial media complex rushed to judgment and allowed virtue-signaling to completely overtake any sense of rationality, or even basic common sense. It never even seemed to occur that, with the extremely limited access track due to COVID-19, catching someone who did this would be incredibly easy and, therefore, someone who works in the NASCAR community would have been willing to destroy their entirety. life in order to make an incredibly stupid and racist gesture.
But having no photo, no rational theory for how or why this happened, and no suspect, is no longer any sort of hurdle for modern news media to become deeply invested in an enticing narrative, no matter how nonsensical. In this case, given NASCAR’s perceived race issues, and the fact that this happened in Alabama, made it particularly easy for critical thinking in the liberal media (and yes, the sports media is at LEAST as liberal as the “mainstream” media is). to be instantly thrown out the car window.
There are those who will, with sincerity, argue that this fiasco was actually NASCAR’s fault because it told the news media that this was a noose and that the FBI is now investigating. Did the media news just understandably rely on what they were being told by an organization that would have no incentive to say that a noose was found in Wallace’s garage?
In short, no. And, moving forward, this might be the most important aspect of this whole controversy.
In my extensive and unique experience, there is very little that the modern news media is worse at than properly interpreting the self-interest of individuals and big-time organizations. In this case, NASCAR actually had a big incentive to fully embrace the “noose” narrative because the costs of not doing so, and being seen as weak in their response, would have been catastrophic, especially in this environment of heightened racial tensions.
In reality, if there was any sort of conspiracy here, it was likely that NASCAR jumped all over a narrative that it knew could be untrue (since it very quickly became apparent that ALL of the garages at Talladega had “nooses” – used to close. The garage doors, it seems unbelievable that no one had a strong suspicion that this was not really a noose), because they knew it would both protect them from what would surely be an intense media attack, as well as promote a popular black driver. . They may have purposely passed it off to the FBI to let them be the “bad guys” to tell the kids in the media (who expressed “shock” all over Twitter after the easy investigation findings were announced) that it wasn’t. actually.
Will there be any accountability for this enormous and easily avoided act of malpractice media? Will there be any apology to NASCAR fans and people of Alabama who are presumed to be racist enough to commit, or at least enable, such a heinous act? Will there be any lessons learned by the news media?
Sadly, but predictably, the answers to these important questions will likely be all negative. No one in the major media gets fired for being wrong in interpreting an event news anymore, at least not if they are incorrect in the wake direction, and ratings for the story are good.
What happened here will definitely happen again, especially in the sports world. Largely because those in the elite media, especially white males, are so incredibly terrified of being canceled for not being awake enough that they would much rather go along with the media herd and be proven wrong, than leave the protection of the media mob, and. risk being run over, even if (especially?) they are right.
John Ziegler is senior columnist for Mediaite, from which this column was adapted.